The End of Publishing?
Friday, September 19, 2008
The story is called "The End," its author is Boris Kachka, and there it sits—a mega feature in New York magazine, heralding the news (the news?) that "the book business as we know it will not be living happily ever after."
http://nymag.com/news/media/50279/
"... pretty much every aspect of the business seems to be in turmoil," Kachka writes. "There’s the floundering of the few remaining semi-independent midsize publishers; the ouster of two powerful CEOs—one who inspired editors and one who at least let them be; the desperate race to evolve into e-book producers; the dire state of Borders, the only real competitor to Barnes & Noble; the feeling that outrageous money is being wasted on mediocre books; and Amazon .com, which many publishers look upon as a power-hungry monster bent on cornering the whole business."
Across an-already vastly partitioned landscape, more fences are being thrown up, the skies are growing darker, and we writers, we readers, we lovers of ideas are—well, what? What are we supposed to be doing? What sort of future waits for us?
Does a future wait for us?
Call me crazy (others have), but I'm still going to bet on a future enriched by books. I'm going to remember that I never was one of those writers who earned a mega advance, or even a big advance, or even, well, you get the point. Indeed, one of my books earned no advance at all (the new "model" of publishing that New York magazine makes reference to); but, heck, that advance-free book went onto sell in several foreign countries, went on to get some bloggers talking, went on to sell out most of its print run. Another book netted me something like $800 after all was said and done—$800 and so many new friends, so many exquisite new opportunities, so many chances to get involved in the life of a city I love, not to mention, the chance to write a book in precisely the way I wanted to write that book, quirky point of view and all.
Writing books gives me an excuse to dwell—with ideas, with language, with research, with people who know more than I do, in places I wish to celebrate. And yes, I'm sad that Barnes & Noble has so much control over my future (literary YA not being high on its buy list at the moment, sad to say). Yes, I wish Amazon wouldn't leverage its power the way that it does, wouldn't insinuate itself so thoroughly into the making-books side of things. Yes, I wish that it were easier, at times, to spread the word about books.
But I'm not giving up on books quite yet. I'm not giving up on writing them, and I'm not giving up on talking about them, or rooting for them. I'm looking up to people like Melissa Walker, who takes three fine books into her own hands, surveys the virtual world, MySpaces and Blogs and Vlogs and FlipBooks and GoodReads and Throws Competitions and Goes ReaderGirlz and gets a lot of people talking about important things in an utterly charming fashion.
The old rules might not apply in publishing anymore. We're going to need some new hiking boots for the trek ahead. But I hope you'll take the journey with me. I hope that we won't ever stand on a hill (or in a valley) and see The End.
12 comments:
Those who value intelligence and knowledge also value books, be they fiction or non-fiction, creative or matter-of-fact, research or escapism. Books will keep on keeping on.
It's tumultuous from all angles, including from the vantage (disadvantage?) point of the aspiring authors. Looking in through the front door of the gleaming metal skyscraper that is the publishing industry, hat and manuscript in hand, one feels there is no solid place to put one's feet as the landscape of the business shape-shifts and the decision-makers become increasingly (and understandably) skittish.
In spite of this, however, I will not - can not - lose faith in books. Books and humans are inseparable, (I truly believe that) just as stories and humans are inseparable. I cling to the belief that markets swell and recede and change and shift, but books always win in the end, one way or another.
What a terrific, honest post, Beth...thank you.
I'm with you on this one. The world may change, but books will always be there. Change can be good, and we just always need to look for the positive side of everything.
And I second Anna's words - terrific post!
I third it! Great post. And thanks for the lovely shout-out. I think we'll keep inventing and creating and writing, those of us who do it for love and not money (which is MOST of us!). Writers are writers are writers, and words won't end. Besides, a creative challenge can be fun if you roll with the tide of change, I believe.
And, I believe in readers. They're there, and they always will be.
You do postings like these, and you hold your breath.
I'm so grateful, therefore, for these responses.
Yes, books rock, and they always will. We're lucky to be alive now, to write now, to talk about all that we love.
Beth, great post. Like others, I can't imagine a future without books and I think (I hope!) they are here to stay. I look at it this way ... even if they do disappear altogether, I have more than enough on my bookshelves to keep me occupied for the rest of my days. (And one of yours, "A Slant of Sun", is on my night table TBR pile, which gets higher priority than the ones on my bookshelves.)
This is my first comment here, but I've been enjoying your blog very much. (Us Philly girls need to stick together, you know ...)
Oh, I feel blessed today. By the gathering of familiar voices here. By the discovery of a new one — Betty and Boo's Mommy.
Welcome to this small but lively family. It's nice to make your acquaintance.
Got my boots on - count me in for the journey. Thank you so much for this post!
I'm in that posse, too! I believe...I believe...
And Melissa, you are so right—for most of us, it's not about the money. Sadly, for big publishers, it is.
I'm strapping on my boots and ready to climb, clamour, and claw...
I feel really honored — very happy — to be embarking on this journey with Laurie and The Ghost Girl.
Honored that they came and journeyed here with me.
Thank you.
I hadn't read that article before but it's incredibly scary stuff. I'm one of those people who is always reading something (and a writer of YA fiction too) so I hope you're right about there being a future for us. The music industry, the film industry and publishing - they all seem to be quite troubled right now. It's a very weird time.
I also have faith in books. Even in our declining economy and the power struggles going on in the industry, I still believe that books will always be there. So glad to see others who feel the same. :)
Post a Comment